A Dialogue on Foreign Policy
A Position Paper
presented to
the Hon. Bill Graham,
Minister of Foreign Affairs, Ottawa
by the Canadian Islamic Congress.
The Canadian Islamic Congress acknowledges with appreciation the initiative
taken by the Hon. Prof. Bill Graham, Minster of Foreign Affairs, to engage
Canadians in discussion about Canada's place in the 21st-century world.
We strongly believe it is the moral duty of every Canadian Muslim to engage in
this discussion. We believe in this country and its leading role in the world
today. We believe that apathy kills freedom, democracy, and our common goal of
achieving social justice at home and peace with justice abroad. We believe in
the following Quranic and Bible quotations on Peace and Justice and urge all
Canadians and our representative government to work toward achieving these
ideals.
"He is God. There is no God but He, The King, The Holy, The Peace." (Qur'an -
59:23)
"There is a time to kill and time to heal, a time to break down and a time to
build, a time to love and time to hate, a time of war and time of peace."
(Bible - Eccl.3:3;8)
"God calls to the Home of Peace." (Qur'an - 10:25)
"Seek peace and pursue it." (Bible - Ps.34:14)
"Pardon them and then say, 'Peace'." (Qur'an - 43:89)
"Love the truth and peace." (Bible - Zech.8:19)
"God enjoins justice, charity and giving to kindred and forbids indecency, evil
and aggression." (Qur'an - 16:90)
"To do justice and judgment is more acceptable to the Lord than sacrifice."
(Bible - Prov.21:3)
"Make peace between them with justice and be fair, as God loves those who are
fair and just." (Qur'an - 49:9)
"Do justly." (Bible - Micah 6:8)
"Let not the hatred of others towards you, swerve you away from being just. Be
just; this is nearer to piety." (Qur'an 49:9)
"Execute true judgment, and show mercy and compassion, every man to his
brother." (Bible - Zech.7:9)
1. Which values and interests should bear most fundamentally on
Canada's foreign policy? How can Canada's foreign policy better reflect the
concerns and priorities of Canadians?
We believe that this great, unique and distinct nation of ours has a mission
for the world, to promote peace and justice and to fight world hunger, poverty,
despair, and human misery.
We believe that Canada has a great deal to gain if its foreign policy is based
on promoting world peace and justice. We further believe that Canada can
contribute to the peaceful resolution of international conflicts.
To build up offensive armaments as a prelude to negotiating is in itself a
threat to world peace. Similarly, the practice of pursuing diplomacy only in a
context where war remains the final court of appeal, is no less detrimental.
War cannot achieve more than peace. Thus, we believe that when diplomacy fails
in resolving international conflicts, the solution is more diplomacy. Even if
some wars are justified or unavoidable, Canada is more qualified to contribute
to efforts at averting them than launching them. This approach is most
consistent with Canadian values.
2. Amid recent global changes, should Canada continue to
endorse a "three pillars" approach to its foreign policy objectives, or should
the current balance be adjusted?
We believe that the theory which interprets history as a series of clashes
between competing civilizations is false and cannot not make our world a better
place. We embrace the basic principle of genuine dialogue between cultures and
societies and are determined to work in that context toward world peace and
justice.
We believe that the permanent division of the world into artificial "have" and
"have-not" zones seriously threatens global peace. Canada can play an
instrumental aid and stewardship role in helping to narrow that gap.
3. Canada is a member of many international organizations, including the G-8,
NATO, the Commonwealth, La Francophonie, the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation
forum (APEC), the Organization of American States (OAS) and the Arctic Council.
Should our participation in any of these be strengthened, or adjusted?
We believe that, although there are still considerable differences between the
methodology used in Ottawa and that used by Washington in resolving
international conflicts, these differences are sadly diminishing.
Canada should be more supportive of the UN; the G8 should be more accommodating
of developing countries; the Commonwealth should be just that, not politically
hijacked by the UK; Canada's membership in NATO should be reviewed; and with
the diversity of originating cultures represented among our citizens Canada
has, and should, play a leading role in APEC, OAS, and La Francophonie to
further promote world peace with justice.
4. In promoting the security of Canadians, where should our priorities lie?
Should Canada give a higher priority to military combat operations? To sectors
such as intelligence-gathering and analysis? Or should we focus on broader
security measures, such as combatting environmental degradation and the spread
of infectious disease? What should be our distinctive role in promoting global
security?
We believe that any deliberate act of violence against innocent people is
immoral. We also believe that people who are under occupation have the right,
as recognized by the UN, to liberate their lands by various means, including
the use of armed resistance. Such armed resistance, as described by the UN,
cannot be labelled "an act of terrorism".
We believe that promoting social justice, both at home and abroad, and
resolving conflicts based on the principles and morals of natural justice is
the best guarantee for achieving global security.
We believe that Canada, a country that refuses to join the global "nuclear
club" despite its ability to do so, has the internationally recognized
credibility to work for the elimination of all weapons of mass-destruction
worldwide: nuclear, biological and chemical.
We applaud our government's efforts to rid the world of anti-personnel land
mines and bomblets, thereby making this planet a safer place for all its
inhabitants; we also applaud Canada's stand regarding the American invasion of
Iraq.
5. How does our military best serve Canadian foreign policy objectives: though
national and continental defense; combat missions in support of international
coalitions; peace-keeping; or all of the above?
We believe that, in addition to the tangible evils of armed conflict -- death,
destruction, poverty, human misery and suffering -- war also promotes, as St.
Augustine aptly noted, "love of violence, revengeful cruelty, fierce and
implacable enmity" and the like.
We believe that every dollar and every intellect devoted to the maintenance of
our outdated war technology is lost, because Canada will never be able to equal
the arsenal of the U.S., nor should we desire this. The return on our economic
and human-resources investment would be far higher if our primary efforts were
directed to promoting international issues of peace and justice. All Canadians
would then know that peace and justice involves them absolutely.
We believe that while peace-keeping is not easy, and peace-making is often very
difficult, our world is in dire need of both -- far more than it needs wars and
enhanced war technologies. Few countries possess the equal of Canada's
reputation, proven experience, ability, and international trust, in the arts of
peace-keeping and peace-making.
6. Should Canada do more to address the root conditions giving rise to conflict
and insecurity beyond our borders? If so, where?
We believe that economic sanctions against any country are fundamentally
counter-productive because they penalize most heavily the very young, the poor,
the sick, and the old. Through its moral authenticity and international trust,
Canada could realize a far greater potential in working with such countries to
achieve changes that sanctions have been unable to accomplish.
We believe that the peoples of Kashmir, Chechnya and Palestine have the
inalienable right to self-determination and statehood. We therefore applaud and
support Canada's stand on the recognition of Palestinian rights, as stipulated
in an ongoing series of related UN resolutions.
We believe that the occupation by Israel of parts of Southern Lebanon, the
Golan Heights, and the West Bank, including parts of Jerusalem, is a violation
of international law and a continuing impediment to world peace. We support
Canada's traditional policy, based on UN Security Council resolutions 242, 338,
and 425 and seek more Canadian diplomatic efforts to implement them.
We believe that minority rights, because they are inherent our recognition of
basic human rights, must be respected in such countries as China, Russia,
India, Burma, and the Philippines. Canada must not hesitate to voice its
concerns and persistently call for the protection of human rights worldwide.
We believe that Canada has a diplomatic role and humanitarian responsibility to
exercise in working to end civil strife in such countries as Algeria and the
Sudan. Canada's international status as a peace-loving and peace-keeping
country would be potentially very effective if our government were to take the
initiative in launching an international diplomatic effort.
7. How should Canada more fully utilize the influence of its location in North
America to increase its national prosperity while retaining and promoting our
distinctive identity?
We believe that Canada, as a respected neighbour and ally of the United States
of America, has a key role to play in moderating the influence American foreign
policy in the interests of achieving world peace and justice.
We believe in the sustainable merit of a Canadian foreign policy which refutes
double standards, racial discrimination, or uncritical appeasement of the
United States.
8. What should Canada do to help spread the benefits of globalization more
widely and equitably among all nations?
We believe that Canada is uniquely situated to promote more collaboration,
cooperation, strategic alliances, and bilateral or multilateral agreements to
deal with global issues of fair trade, education, and cultural exchange. Canada
should take a proactive stand now in favour of equitable globalization, for the
alternative is globalization-turned-colonization, not only in economics, but
also in politics, culture and even military outcomes. Canada could enhance
positive outcomes for globalization in a number of ways, including the sharing
of its IT (information technology) resources with the developing world.
9. Should Canada focus on cultivating new economic partnerships with emerging
global powers such as China, India, Mexico and Brazil?
We believe that Canada should work to lessen its dependence on trade with the
US. In addition to encouraging more trade relationships with China, India,
Mexico and Brazil, we should also work toward increased trade with the Muslim
world and its nearly 1.5 billion citizens, of which 650,000 live in Canada.
10. Are values such as human rights, democracy, respect for diversity, and
gender equality ones that Canada should continue to advocate in all parts of
the world? If so, what are the best ways of achieving this?
As noted above, we believe that the theory which interprets history as a series
of clashes between civilizations is false and does not make our world a better
place. We embrace dialogue among cultures and societies and are determined to
work on multiple fronts to further global peace and justice.
11. Should Canada actively seek out opportunities for fostering global
intercultural dialogue and interfaith understanding?
We believe that God Almighty created humanity to enjoy, not to destroy, the
fruits of the earth and of human toil. The Arabic word "Islam" is derived from
the same root as the word peace, or "salam." In the religious sense, a Muslim
is one who voluntarily submits his/her will and actions -- in peace -- to the
will, love, and guidance of God Almighty.
We believe that Canadian Muslims contribute substantially to the well-being of
this country. They are proud to be Canadian, as much as they are proud to be
Muslim. Their faith, their spirituality and their culture add a unique and rich
dimension to the Canadian mosaic.
We believe that Islam, as a religion, an ideology and a world view, is a
progressive force in the advancement of the human race toward attaining world
peace and justice. History is a witness that when Muslims closely followed the
teachings of Islam they, and the rest of the world, prospered. Whenever Muslims
did not follow the teachings of Islam they, and the rest of the world, suffered
greatly.
12. What are the best means for Canada to make its culture and experience known
abroad?
We believe that Canadian faith leaders, Canadian NGOs, and universities can
play a leading role. The Canadian Islamic Congress is willing to serve in this
regard.
In Conclusion:
We believe that Canadian foreign policy is gradually abandoning Canada's
traditional role as a peace-making and peace-keeping nation, and that this is
exerting a strong negative impact on our domestic affairs. Canadians are losing
their historic sense of national unity and their pride in compassionately
caring for our poor, young, old, sick, disabled, and unemployed, is steadily
eroding.
We believe that, for the well-being of all Canadians, the spirit of former PM
Lester Bowles Pearson must be maintained in Canada's 21st-century foreign
policy. Pearson's positive efforts to resolve the Suez Canal Crisis while
Secretary of State for External Affairs (1948-57) were rewarded with the 1957
Nobel Peace Prize. And later, as Prime Minister, he introduced a comprehensive
pension plan for the old, a national Medicare plan for the sick, and united our
people around a new Canadian flag, recognized the world over as the proud
symbol of a just and caring nation.
We believe also that Canada stands to greatly benefit financially from a
well-balanced approach to world problems, especially in the Muslim world. The
world's nearly 1.5 billion Muslims represent a huge potential market and Muslim
countries could soon be at the head of Canada's list of major trading partners.
We hope that you will review and respond to our position paper.
For The Canadian Islamic Congress,
Prof. Mohamed Elmasry, FRSC, FCAE, FIEEE
National President
np@canadianislamiccongress.com